Poet Giovanni calls Blackwell S.O.B. at Square
If Ken Blackwell does manage to become Ohio's governor, don't look for Nikki Giovanni to be appointed the state's poet laureate.
Giovanni, a native Cincinnatian, read an original poem entitled "I am Cincinnati,'' a paean to all that is good and great about the Queen City, like three-way chili and Spring Grove Cemetery. She read her poem during re-opening ceremonies to the new Fountain Square.
Then came this part of the poem:
"I am not a son of a bitch like Kenny Blackwell," Giovanni said, adding that Cincinnati is "not a political whore.''
First, there was a collective gasp from the crowd. Then applause and some amens.
Blackwell campaign spokesman Carlo LoParo said Giovanni's remarks showed "a total lack of class.''
"People are going to disagree in politics; we understand that, but there is something to be said for civility,'' LoParo said. "She is utterly without class.''
36 Comments:
What are Carlo LoParo's credentials in terms of poetry? Is he a poet? Another kind of artist? Does he have a degree in literature?
If not, I find his opinion completely off-topic.
Meanwhile, after an aggressive early advertising push, Republican gubernatorial nominee Ken Blackwell has disappeared from the airwaves until Oct. 29. It is a surprising turn of events for the leading candidate on the party's ticket, notwithstanding his lag in the polls.
In a letter to supporters earlier this month, the group's chairman, Massachusetts Gov. Mitt Romney, listed Iowa, Maine, Oregon, Illinois, Arkansas and Michigan as the only states with targeted governor's races.
I think Blackwell's problem is likeability. No one likes him. He is arrogant and nasty. He is also an opportunist who would do anything to get ahead.
City Beat has written probably the most comprehensive article on Blackwell. They quote extensively from his book. This man is also scary extreme.
http://www.citybeat.com/2006-08-16/cover.shtml
Calling Blackwell a SOB is a compliment. He's a traitor to his race and nation. He's a fascist theocrat, a thief, a liar and a modern day Jim Crow.
the dean of cincinnati is an idiot
http://www.umich.edu/~eng499/people/giovanni.html
please go write another anti-hemilich piece of garbage. we know that since you have a degree in lietrature" it will mean something. if you dont ahve a degree folks keep yoru mouth shut
What are Nicki Giovanni's credentials in terms of politics? Is she a politician? Another kind of public figure? Does she have a degree in political science?
If not, I find her opinion completely off-topic...and classless.
No, she's not a "son of a bitch". She's just a plain old bitch.
That was a complete classless display at what is supposed to be a non-political event for the whole community. Shame on the bitch, and shame on those who would invite such a bitch to speak at this event.
The Republicans have Finney
The Democrats have Giovanni(sic)
One's a liar and both are crass.
The Dean,
I was an English major, with expertise in contemporary literary criticism. And I can tell you, her poem shows a complete lack of class.
What a ridiculous and classless thing to say.
Everyone is afraid to tell the truth. Nikki Giovanni is NOT a poet of any stature or quality. Calling the man an "SOB" isn't poetry or outspokenness. It's just plain garbage.
I'm voting for Ted Strickland because he's the better man for the job and I'm NO fan of Ken Blackwell.
But, I'm less a fan of people like this poet using our city's opening of the square to act in such a classless manner.
Shame on you Ms. Giovanni.
This kind of nonsense is why people flock to NKY in droves. Go ahead liberals, keep it up. The Levee needs our business. While you're at it be sure to invite the thugs from Avondale, Bond Hill and Over the Rhine down to serve as greeters for out of town guests
3CDC owes the citizens and apology.
What are Nicki Giovanni's credentials in terms of politics?
In the end, politics is about people. I think she is one, too.
Who was in charge of this event? Who invited Nikki to speak? Did they lok at her poem ahead of tiem? How much did the taxpayers pay for this event? How much did the taxpayers pay Nikki for her hate speech?
These are all questions that should be asked of City Council, the County COmmissioners, etc.
"What are Carlo LoParo's credentials in terms of poetry? Is he a poet? Another kind of artist? Does he have a degree in literature?
If not, I find his opinion completely off-topic."
you go use your literature degree to examine poems like this and get out of the political business till you have a degree in political science. You are nothing but a hack
Just a question that I didn't see answered, but might have missed it: Did someone from 3CDC review her poem before she read it?
Now people want 3CDC to play government censors? You've got to be kidding!
This just shows the utter and complete hypocrisy of the left. Isn't this hate speech? No doubt she will be hailed as "courageous" by the media. Let's see if the PC Enquirer condemns this. Don't hold your breath. What a complete lack of class. Why was she even invited? Her politics are so left of center and out of the mainstream. It's no wonder moderates (black and white) are leaving this city in droves. Is this person and her hateful views what Cincinnati is supposed to represent?
If this doesn't demonstrate the sheer and utter hypocrisy of the left, nothing ever will. Isn't this exactly the type of "hate speech" the left condemns? I guess it doesn't apply if you are talking about a conservative black republican.
Why was this person even invited to speak at this type of non-political celebration? Her radical and hateful views are well known? Why didn't Mallory or Luken rebuke her? I guess some people get a pass.
No doubt the local media will label her "courageous" for her comments. Let's just see if the PC Enquirer condemns her. When pigs fly, as they say.
Is it any wonder that moderate people (black and white) are abandoning this City in droves? When radicals such as Nikki Giovanni are put up front as being representative of what this City stands for, people will continue to vote with their feet and the exodus will continue. Warren County, here we come.
If Ohioans won't listen to John Conyers, Maxine Waters, the entire Congressional Black Caucus, authors of numerous books on Blackwell, innumerable news reports and his own dispicable record, maybe they'll understand it in the terms Ms. Giovanni uses. Good for her. This sterilized city and their stupid million dollar fountain move need to be shook up. And Giovanni is unparelleled in her field.
Even more classless than the comment is the ignorant commenter trying to turn this into a NKY vs. Cincinnati issue. I'm sure that the Levee's business share is being driven by poetry--that's why most of the upper level of the Levee gallery is empty.
We shall see, when the square sits empty and the hip-hoppers roam all over, where the people are; because they won't be anywhere near the square.
You can't stand the truth. Blackwell has turned this state into a national joke, he's suppressed votes, he's failed to address huge problems in election systems and access, and he's part of the most corrupt administration in any statehouse in America. Don't you get it, Ohio is a free for all for political crooks.
And people gripe when a poet tells the truth. Who else speaks up? Where are the business leaders as the state is in economic free-fall and turning into a political joke before our very eyes?
Will the last honest politician who leaves Ohio please turn off the lights.
These are some of the dumbest comments I have ever read.
Hate speech? Are you kidding? Do those of you making the accusation even know what hate speech is?
Hate speech is not a political opinion expressed towards an active candidate.
Jeff, you're calling Nikki Giovanni a bitch while accusing her of lacking class? The irony is too obvious.
The part of this conversation that bewilders me most is that you are all sooo shocked an artist expressed an opinion through her art form.
Art and politics are so intertwined it shouldn't be shocking to hear a poem of this nature. Going out to a public square, a place designed to be a meeting place for the citizens, should be a place to leave the local Republican club behind for a mintue and actually hear someone say something you're not used to. That's life.
If Cincinnati achieved the level of excellence Nikki Giovanni has achieved in the field of poetry, we wouldn't have any problems in the world.
If you want to demand class of someone, ask your politicians to change their cheap and dirty advertisements.
To answer one of the common questions: Yes, I imagine someone from 3CDC saw the poem since there is an excerpt of the work on the back of the event program.
You know what other son of a bitch was utterly without class? George W. Bush. That bastard spewed hate speech like Mark Foley on a keyboard when he had the nerve to call Kenny Blackwell "a secretary of state who's a nut." Were taxpayer dollars used to fund Bush's comments? Get the Congress and the Supreme Court on the case right away. How dare he hurt little Kenny's sensitive feelings?
I can't stand Blackwell
And I wouldn't be impressed with her poem even if I read it in private, for pleasure (though theline about Balckwell would have given me a chuckle) - it just didn't do anything for me
But, at a public event, a family gathering place, during the day, government sanctioned activity ---
There is no excuse for these vulgarities -- we are cincinnati
WE ARE CINCINATI
A Cheap Shot - this type of political diatribe is inappropriate at the inaugaration of Fountain Square. Blackwell is an SOB right? - ? Just politcial commentary on the public soap box and the communtiy dime. Guess the 3CDC folks aren't much cleverer than the elected folks they are looking to upstage. Nothing like bringing the city together. This ought to go far in encouraging folks to visit the city core.
It is awfully easy for white people to sneer. After all their franchise has never been suppessed. If you think the GOP doesn't use suppression in any state that has a higher proportion of African Americans than Idaho then you need to wake up.
The GOP's Shameful Vote Strategy
Time was when Republicans were at least embarrassed by their efforts to keep African Americans from the polls. Today's Republicans have elevated vote suppression from a dirty secret to a public norm.
http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/articles/A707-2004Oct26.html
Anonymous said...
We shall see, when the square sits empty and the hip-hoppers roam all over, where the people are; because they won't be anywhere near the square.
6:28 PM, October 15, 2006
Is there anyone else who sees this comment for the racist comment sit is?
Even if you take out the classless comments about Blackwell, that's still the biggest piece of crap "poem" I've ever seen! It's amazing what's passed off as "art" these days. To call Giovanni a poet is right up there with calling Charlie Luken sober.
Correction: Nikki Giovanni is not a Cincinnati native. Although she grew up in Cincinnati, she was born in Knoxville.
What is this world coming to, when an American-- ANY American - can't speak her mind without this kind of backlash? Is this the type of Rigid Right-Wing extremism Blackwell stands for? I'd say Nikki's right!
Nikki Giovanni is an excellent poet, and if it surpasses your ability to comprehend I apologize, you are obviously too much of a home schooled closed minded dilettante too appreciate her work. Maybe you just didn’t enjoy this particular piece. I recommend you take a look at others, perhaps you might relate to “Gus” or “The December of My Springs.” In fact, what other poems of hers are you familiar with? Now before you jump on Google and read “Ego Trippin” save yourself the time, because it’s clear to everyone who reads this forum that you have not. But maybe…just maybe you have read a broad array of her poetry and still don’t like her work; in that case you are well within your right to say that you don’t like her poetry, but to say that she is a “bitch” for expressing a viewpoint through her art that you disagree with is not just ignorant, it is unpatriotic. God save us from the day when the public figures in our country are censored, and can’t speak against evil where and when they see it, God save us from a day when a 63 year old lady barely pushing 5 feet with one lung and nothing to defend herself but a sharp wit, a sterling intellect, and a mind of her own can’t do battle with corrupt politicians via her poetry.
How long have you known Ms. Giovanni sir, how many mornings have you talked with her, listened to her thoughts and heard her wonderfully different view on the world from a perspective that is unique to her. I would wager none, and that this is the first time she has disturbed the tranquility of your stagnant mind with her reprimanding of a corrupt and evil man. Just this morning Nikki spoke about the controversy her poem is inspiring, and the threats that are cluttering her inbox from people just like you, and she said something particularly wise. She said, “the best response to poetry is poetry” and I would have to agree. If you have something educated to say about Nikki, some well thought out and rational reason why she shouldn’t have said what she said, please feel free to share it with me and anyone else who will listen. But please, don’t waste everyone’s time by hatemongering trying to bully an intelligent and passionate woman, trying to use what influence she has to save the world from another evil politician.
Name calling is the hobgoblin of little minds as you have so well illustrated, and though Nikki did use the same word she was not name calling, it was an outcry of shame, anger and sadness at the way this man would defile a city that she loves. She is exercising her freedom of speech as she has done for years, and she is entitled to that liberty. Don’t you dare stomp on that!
And by the way anonymous at 11:01, if you are CINCINATI (sic) as you claim (“There is no excuse for these vulgarities -- we are cincinnati WE ARE CINCINATI)”
You might want to check your spelling; Cincinnati has two “n’s.”
Did any of you clowns even READ the poem?
http://news.enquirer.com/apps/pbcs.dll/article?AID=/20061017/NEWS01/310170004
"Anonymous" is somewhat correct when he/she wrote:
"Nikki Giovanni is an excellent poet." [Note that after 'closed minded dilettante' it should read "to" not "too"]
See the following BLOG for more discussion: http://dividedlives.blogspot.com/
Yes I had noticed that after I posted. I figured it wasn't worth another post to correct the missing "o." I'm glad I left it because it gave you something to respond with since nobody seems to be arguing what I said. I will take it as a compliment that in a one page reponse the only thing you could find to argue was a tiny typo.
Make that extra "o"
* Our online blogs currently are hosted and operated by a third party, namely, Blogger.com. You are now leaving the Cincinnati.Com website and will be linked to Blogger.com's registration page. The Blogger.com site and its associated services are not controlled by Cincinnati.Com and different terms of use and privacy policy will apply to your use of the Blogger.com site and services.
By proceeding and/or registering with Blogger.com you agree and understand that Cincinnati.Com is not responsible for the Blogger.com site you are about to access or for any service you may use while on the Blogger.com site.
<< Home