NAACP: Smitherman Can't Be Both
If you're following the back-and-forth about whether Christopher Smitherman can be both local NAACP president and a City Council candidate, here's another round:
Richard McIntire, a spokesman for the NAACP national office in Baltimore, says tonight that Smitherman cannot. He says the organization has a policy dating to 1968 that requires anyone in a local leadership role to "relinquish their position temporarily during the period of the candidacy." The policy also says that if the person wins the elected office, he or she has to resign the NAACP position, according to McIntire. He said he couldn't fax the policy.
If it seems like you read something different than that here earlier this week, you're not imagining it. McIntire said Wednesday, in a voicemail, that the organization's constitution didn't speak to the issue. He said then:
"Customarily, what occurs is if there is a branch president that is seeking elective office in their community, once they announce as a candidate, they will step down as president. The branch's first vice president will assume the presidency. And then pending the outcome of the election, if that individual were successful in their run for elective office, it would be up to the branch to determine or vote whether or not there was a conflict of interest and then they would proceed accordingly."
As for the discrepancy, McIntire said Friday that he and I must have misunderstood each other.
16 Comments:
Go John Eby!
I guess this just means that the NAACP can't handle having a successful black man on Cincinnati City Council.
.
Isn't it fascinating when groups try to 'coast' through life only to find themselves being eaten by their own ?
We suppose it's the other spoiled 'dark meat', turning 'green' !
PATHETIC !
HAD ENOUGH, VOTE for a real DEMOCRAT 2007 !
There's a difference between customs, rule and bylaws. Why can't the clown just fax actual rules.
Julian Bond, Charles McIntire, Chris Smitherman.
Why doesn't anyone take the NAACP seriously anymore?
Richard McIntire, sorry.
Anyone who's ever worked anywhere knows there are policies that are documented and those that aren't.
In my experience the documented policies tend to represent position statements. "It is the official policy of XYZ that blah, blah, blah."
Organizational policies often derive from tradition and oral history rather than workplace manuals and conditions of employment/service.
Net: while it would behoove the NAACP to have a documented policy/position statement on the practice of Chapter officers campaigning for and/or holding elected public office, it's not unenforceable that this one isn't, particularly given the surfeit of anecdotal information that "traditionally" officers step down. One can disagree with Marian Spencer for her support of Smitherman generally, but she is to be commended for holding the line on this question of principle without regard to its effect upon him.
This is just plain wrong, he should be able to do both. Shame on the national office for not having there act together.
www.dumpdewine.com
McIntire changed his story because there are people in high places in this city who do not want Smitherman to be a City Councilman and President of the Cincinnati NAACP chapter. That would be a great deal of power for a person to have. According to the NAACP by-laws, McIntire was closer to the truth with his voicemail on Thursday. His statement on Friday contradicts not only his statement on Thursday, but the NAACP by-laws itself. NAACP by-laws state that the Executive Committee of the local NAACP branch determines if there's a conflict of interest and that's ONLY IF the President wins a seat on City Council. The National Office, according to the by-laws, cannot make that determination.
Why would anyone want Chris Smitherman back on Council? He's nothing but an anti-police, me-first grandstander.
Just because we want some oversight of the police department and don't kiss their leadership's asses don't make us anti-cop. It makes us pro-transparent and accountable government.
Smitherman will win again!
Who is "we"?
Not letting the police do their jobs is anti-police. Feeling the need to have "oversight" is grandstanding and self-serving.
Cincinnati needs council members who will focus on things like reducing the crime rate, increasing home ownership, and getting the Banks project done. The city doesn't need a person like Smitherman who is only interested in making a name for himself and being an agitator.
The fact that he didn't get re-elected last time speaks volumes. Apparently he hasn't gotten the message yet.
Chris Smitherman. This guy is a true piece of work. I love it when he is in the news. That way the afternoon talk show with Bill Cunningham is super funny with his Smitherman takes. Great radio. Keep it up Chris, we love your act!
Smitherman!
Who's the black NAACP president
That's a truth machine to all the residents?
(Smitherman!)
You're damn right
Who is the man
That would risk his neck for his brother man?
(Smitherman!)
Can ya dig it?
Who's the cat that won't cop out
When there's fat cat politicos all about
(Smitherman!)
Right on
You see this cat Smitherman is a bad mother--
(Shut your mouth)
But I'm talkin' about Smitherman
(Then we can dig it)
He's an real, honest man
Who we all trust and understand.
(Christopher Smitherman)
Right on
Am i the only one to see this? Chris cries to the national office for help when he feels like he is beaten in an election.
then he says the rules they make do not mean anything.
either they have authority or they dont. how can he have it both ways?
how can smitherman complain to the naacp and ask for help when he doesnt like the local decision (1st election results), and then defy them when he doesnt agree with their policy?
this man seems to have a lot of support, but it boggles my mind. he can not have it both ways. either he recognizes the authority of the national organization, or he doesnt. if he doesnt, then edith should still be president of the local chapter.
* Our online blogs currently are hosted and operated by a third party, namely, Blogger.com. You are now leaving the Cincinnati.Com website and will be linked to Blogger.com's registration page. The Blogger.com site and its associated services are not controlled by Cincinnati.Com and different terms of use and privacy policy will apply to your use of the Blogger.com site and services.
By proceeding and/or registering with Blogger.com you agree and understand that Cincinnati.Com is not responsible for the Blogger.com site you are about to access or for any service you may use while on the Blogger.com site.
<< Home